The Florida Department of Environmental Protection has ordered the city of Fort Pierce to pay nearly $16,000 by July 17. Documents WPTV obtained from the FDEP claim the city has been operating docks on state-owned submerged land at Little Jim without the required permits since 2021. The FDEP action, issued in June, comes amid a lawsuit filed by local resident Kevin Keene. Fort Pierce city commissioners voted unanimously Monday night to reject a settlement offer in the lawsuit alleging years of waterfront mismanagement tied to historic restaurant Little Jim Bait & Tackle. Under the proposed settlement terms, Keene would have dropped the case if the city halted any new plans for Little Jim until permit issues are resolved and allowed a public vote on future waterfront land decisions.

City Commissioner Michael Broderick acknowledged the permit issue, saying his information is that the accusation is actually true, that there was an extension of the existing docks. Broderick said someone at some point extended the docks further than allowed.

He plans to negotiate FDEP's fines down while the city investigates who authorized the extension. The city has filed a motion to dismiss Keene's amended complaint. The dispute traces back to last year when the Fort Pierce landmark of nearly 80 years was facing an uncertain future after its lease expired.