The Fort Pierce City Commission on Monday unanimously rejected a third settlement proposal in a citizen lawsuit over the Little Jim Bait and Tackle property and instead countered with an offer to drop the city's claim for legal costs if plaintiff Kevin Keene withdraws his case. Commissioner Arnold Gaines said the settlement demand that Little Jim's current operator be given the right to match the outcome of any future bids to lease the city-owned property would violate state law.

Public entities are required to competitively bid the awarding of things like property leases to get the best outcome for taxpayers. Gaines suggested giving Little Jim's current operator an automatic right of first refusal would violate the principle of competitive bidding.

Commissioners decided to offer a counter settlement saying they will forgo a claim for the city's legal costs involved in defending the lawsuit, a minimum $3,600, if Keene drops his action. Keene, a Fort Pierce resident, filed suit against the city in October as an attempt to give citizens more authority in determining how city-owned waterfront property is used. A St. Lucie County judge has twice dismissed Keene's lawsuit but gave him an opportunity to refile.

Little Jim, a former military guard post that was given to the city by the Navy after World War II, has been embroiled in controversy for more than a year over claims the current operator installed unpermitted docks that encroached on state-owned property, plus issues surrounding the 2025 award of a new lease to operate the property. The current operator, Salty Baitshack 3, has continued business there on a month-to-month lease for more than a year.

Keene's latest settlement offer would require the city to suspend any new Requests for Proposals for awarding the next long-term Little Jim lease until all issues with the Florida Department of Environmental Protection have been resolved. It would also require the city to agree to put any future sale or long-term lease of publicly owned waterfront property to a citywide vote and give Little Jim's current operator the right to match the highest bid resulting from an RFP process. A new lease would be for no more than nine years and the property would be leased in its existing condition, without requiring or conditioning the new lease upon any additional improvements, alterations, redevelopment, or other changes to the property.