The Martin County School Board voted this week to reinstate Spectrum Academy teacher Matthew Theobald and rescind his suspension and termination after adopting a judge’s recommendation. The judge had ruled that Theobald’s social media comments about conservative activist Charlie Kirk’s death did not justify suspension or dismissal. Theobald will also be awarded back pay and benefits through June 30.

The Martin County School District sought to dismiss Theobald over several online comments following Kirk’s murder in Utah in September 2025. The school board voted to suspend Theobald without pay and recommended his termination. Both parties agreed to an administrative hearing to address the matter.

In June, the judge ruled that the school board failed to prove Theobald engaged in immorality or willful neglect of duty, which would have been grounds for dismissal. The judge also found that Theobald’s Facebook comments did not disrupt his students or the learning environment, or reduce any teacher’s ability to teach. District leadership said after the ruling that it would review the recommendation.

School board member Marsha Powers said she voted in favor of the decision but questioned the process. “I have serious concerns about the process that brought this matter before a judge who does not live or work in the community,” Powers said.

Board member Tony Anderson said he understood Powers’ concerns but noted that the board had already placed the issue in the judge’s hands. “It’s a decision we have to live with,” Anderson said.