Christopher 'Doc' Collins won the open Martin County Commission District 2 seat Tuesday, defeating Susan O'Rourke and Althea Wiley in a Universal Primary Contest that decided the race outright. Collins received 14,657 votes, or about 49 percent, while O'Rourke received 12,065 votes, about 40 percent, and Wiley received 3,194 votes, nearly 11 percent. Because all three candidates were Republicans and no Democrat qualified, Tuesday's vote decided the seat with no November general election to follow.

Collins, a chiropractor and former Stuart city commissioner and mayor, stepped down from the Stuart City Commission earlier this year to run for the county seat, a move required under the city's charter before he could qualify for another elected office. He ran largely on a platform of slow growth, calling for tighter restrictions on new development across the county. During his time on the Stuart City Commission, Collins joined two other commissioners in voting to rescind the city's agreement with Brightline for a downtown train station, a position that put him at odds with O'Rourke throughout the campaign.

The campaign had a tense moment in its final week, when Collins accused a man named Jim Gallegos of stealing his campaign signs, posting a Facebook video with trail camera footage and Apple AirTag tracking he said showed Gallegos pulling one of his signs from the ground. Gallegos denied stealing anything, saying he removed roughly 30 signs for various candidates, including some of Collins', at a property owner's request. The dispute also drew in Derreck Ogden, a Stuart City Commission candidate, who publicly confronted Gallegos over the signs.

Collins will replace outgoing Commissioner Stacey Hetherington, who chose not to seek re election. O'Rourke, a former traffic engineer who previously served on Stuart's Local Planning Agency, ran on managing growth and easing traffic congestion. Her candidacy became the subject of a legal dispute earlier this year after Collins filed a challenge seeking to have her removed from the ballot, arguing she was not legally a Martin County resident when she qualified.

A judge dismissed that challenge in July. Wiley, an author, Realtor and chef, ran on affordability, pointing to rising housing costs and other everyday expenses facing county residents.