Robert John Davison, who served as secretary of Aerie 4374 Fraternal Order of Eagles in Vero Beach from February 2015 until November 2024, allegedly spent nearly $419,000 of the organization's money on personal purchases. The investigation began after a representative from the Grand Aerie examined why membership and finances were declining at the chapter. The representative discovered that Davison had been using the organization's debit card for unauthorized personal purchases.

The organization hired forensic accounting firm Clay Price & Associates, P.A. to review financial records. On February 24, 2025, the firm reported that Davison had used $418,899.26 in organization funds for personal expenses dating back to 2017. The alleged spending included $8,791.14 on firearms, ammunition, personal purchases and an NRA membership, $35,094.53 in personal grocery and liquor store purchases, and at least $2,461.37 in purchases for Davison's personal LEGO business.

Other alleged expenses included $4,463.52 in personal court payments including child support and DUI-related fees, $55,175.40 on personal bills including credit cards and vehicle payments, $115,087.49 in ATM withdrawals and associated fees, $9,861.27 in transfers to Davison's personal Cash App account, $16,038.66 in unauthorized flights and lodging, $5,930.98 in rideshare expenses, and $2,476.43 in personal fuel purchases. Davison is accused of embezzlement involving a value of $100,000 or more.