The St. Lucie County Fire District's leadership crisis has deepened after firefighters delivered an overwhelming no-confidence vote and a fire board member publicly called for Chief Jeff Lee's resignation. The district has been under scrutiny since an investigation into alleged hazing at Station 1A led to the firing of three veteran firefighters and the resignation of district attorney Kim Sabol, who had faced several complaints. Now a union vote shows more than 74% of participating firefighters have no confidence in Lee, and Fire Board member and St. Lucie County Commissioner James Clasby says the chief should step down.
Clasby called the vote a wake-up call and said it is now up to the board to take action. Asked whether that action should include Lee's resignation, Clasby said yes, adding that he does not see how Lee could recover from such an overwhelming vote of no confidence. The same union vote found about 92% of participating firefighters had no confidence in Assistant Chief Brian Gonzalez and 97% had no confidence in Sabol, who has submitted notice of her retirement, effective in December.
A reassignment notice shows Gonzalez is being moved from assistant chief to battalion chief, a move Clasby questioned given the no-confidence numbers against him. He said he has questions about why someone who received over 90% no confidence would be moved into a training position responsible for training the entire district. The district said Gonzalez and Lee agreed the reassignment was in the district's best interest and said the move had been under discussion for some time before recent events. In a statement, the district said it recognizes the results of the no-confidence vote and remains committed to addressing workplace concerns and taking appropriate action to protect the safety, well-being and trust of its firefighters.
The no-confidence vote traces back to an investigation earlier this year into videos involving firefighters at Station 1A. A third-party investigator concluded the videos depicted hazing, including one showing firefighters using a modified bug zapper to shock probationary employees. Veteran firefighters Doug Boudrias, Jordan Hutchinson and Chris Baldwin were fired following the investigation, though all three have maintained the activity was consensual. Union representative Ryan Sapp, who represents the three firefighters in their fight for reinstatement, said previous settlement offers are now off the table and that Lee told him he does not believe a change in leadership would resolve the confidence or morale issues.
The Fire Board is weighing whether it has the authority to reinstate the three fired firefighters and is working to overhaul how complaints against district leadership are handled. That effort is expected to continue at the board's Oct. 21 meeting.



