A criminal case against Paige O'Donnell, the Palm City woman accused in the hoarding of 36 border collies rescued from her Martin County home in August, is moving toward its next hearing on Dec. 1. O'Donnell faces 72 criminal charges, two for each dog rescued, including an animal cruelty and improper confinement charge for every dog. She has pleaded not guilty.
O'Donnell was not present at her docket sounding Thursday afternoon at the Martin County courthouse. Her attorney, Russell Ferraro, said the defense only recently received discovery in the case. "We just got the discovery in the case yesterday," Ferraro said. "We're organizing it, going through it, and we'll take it from there." Ferraro declined to characterize the case for or against his client at this stage, saying, "At this point I can't really say anything on her behalf for or against her." He added, "Everybody's got a right to a fair trial and to due process."
It has been just under two months since Martin County deputies removed the 36 dogs from O'Donnell's feces-filled home in August. Martin County condemned the house days after the border collies were rescued. Ferraro said O'Donnell is staying elsewhere while the house undergoes repair.
While the criminal case continues, most of the rescued dogs have found new homes. According to the Humane Society of the Treasure Coast, 30 of the 36 dogs have been adopted, five have gone or are about to go to animal rescues, and one remains up for adoption. Among the adopters, Cale and Colleen Tilley near Deltona each took in one of the rescued border collies, now named Nadia and Leila.
Tilley said Leila was frightened when she first arrived home in September, hiding under the bed rather than going near the front door, but has since warmed up. "Now she just runs straight through the sliding glass door, or into it," Tilley said. Cale said Nadia goes to work with him every day and typically warms up to new people once offered a treat.
Both adopters said their dogs have been working through old habits, including jumping onto countertops, which Tilley speculated was tied to how the dogs previously got food. Tilley, who showed dogs with her family as a child, said she remembered O'Donnell's reputation for well-bred and well-trained dogs and said she has struggled to understand what happened. Cale said he had been grieving the loss of his previous border collie, Jessie, who died of cancer about a year before he learned about the dogs from Palm City. "You just never know when the right dog is gonna come along, and this was the right dog," Cale said.



