A Florida couple who carried both flood and homeowners insurance before the 2024 hurricane season received payments from their insurer and FEMA but remain on an empty lot nearly two years later, unable to rebuild. Jen and RJ Garbowicz lost their home to flooding during Hurricane Helene in 2024, then sustained roof damage 13 days later during Hurricane Milton. The couple paid between $18,000 and $20,000 annually for both types of insurance.

The Garbowicz couple's flood insurance through FEMA's National Flood Insurance Program paid out the maximum of $250,000. Their mortgage holder is holding $200,000 of that payout, leaving the couple only $50,000 to rebuild. FEMA required the couple to rebuild under the 50% rule.

After appealing four times by submitting the same documentation repeatedly, they received approval for a $33,000 FEMA disaster grant. The couple qualified for an SBA disaster loan but were told they must first cover the difference between insurance payments received and the total cost of rebuilding with their own cash. They also must repay the $33,000 FEMA grant before receiving the SBA loan.

Florida Emergency Management Director Kevin Guthrie, who served on the President's FEMA Review Council, told an insurance workshop in June that the average FEMA payout is $4,500. Guthrie urged insurance companies to ensure policyholders understand that FEMA will not make homeowners whole. The Garbowicz couple traveled to Washington, D.C., with the Extreme Weather Survivors group to advocate for the FEMA Act, a House proposal that would reform the agency.

The bill would make FEMA an independent agency by removing it from the Department of Homeland Security, create a universal application process for disaster recovery, process FEMA grants faster by providing money to homeowners before recovery rather than as reimbursement, and facilitate investment in mitigation efforts and damage prevention before storms hit.

The couple estimates they have another 18 to 24 months of rebuilding ahead. RJ Garbowicz said the proposed reforms would have helped them rebuild sooner. Jennifer Garbowicz said getting their story out through interviews and putting pressure on lawmakers is what it will take to drive change. The couple remains in legal discussions with their homeowners insurance company over one claim.